Vale ignored warning before deadly Brumadinho dam collapse

Tuesday, 05 November 2019 00:17:06 (GMT+3)   |   Sao Paulo

Vale’s top executives allegedly received an anonymous email warning about the faulty dams at Brumadinho weeks before the deadly tragedy, a media report from the Wall Street Journal said this week, mentioning a police document.

The media report said an email sent on January 9, 2019, about two weeks before the collapse, warned several Vale executives, including then CEO Fabio Schvartsman, CFO Luciano Siani Pires and others, the dams were “at their limit.”

Vale told the WSJ the email was “generic” and lacked evidence. According to the letter, Vale had “great challenges ahead,” as operations lacked  “the minimum level of adequate investment.”

“We are lacking personnel in the operational, maintenance and engineering areas and they are poorly remunerated…equipment is breaking, the dams are at their limit,” the anonymous email said.

According to police documents, then-CEO Schvartsman tried, unsuccessfully, to find out who wrote the email after the collapse took place.

The WSJ media report noted authorities “believed Vale was concerned that any problems at its dams could spook shareholders following the collapse of another dam it jointly owned in 2015 that killed 19 people.”

Marketplace Offers

DRI

Dimensions 9 - 16 mm
 
Tedarikçi SUEZ STEEL CO.
View Offer

Lumps

Dimensions 0 mm
 
Tedarikçi ATAY COMPANY
View Offer

Lumps

Dimensions 0 mm
 
Tedarikçi Wuchan zhongda international group
View Offer

Similar articles

Vale's Q3 2026 net profit falls 53 percent as iron ore fines prices drop

Samarco's Q3 2026 production at highest level since operations resumed in 2020

Iron ore miner Cedro Mineração to grow pellet feed production in Brazil

Vale seeks regulatory nod for stake in Ligga iron ore mine in northern Brazil

CSN chief executive steps aside and appoints former Vale CEO to role

Vale net profit declines 34 percent in Q2 2026 versus year earlier

MRS approves new 15-year iron ore transport agreement with Vale

Vale inaugurates AI-based model plant in Brazil to improve mining safety and efficiency

Brazilian miner Vale expands lifespan of Itabira iron ore mine

Vale achieves production record in 2025, suspends two mines in Minas Gerais