WSD Strategic Insights CLXXXVIII: Tariff “Wild Cards”

Monday, 16 December 2024 14:13:25 (GMT+3)   |   San Diego

Enter the USA “wild cards” throughout the election cycle, “strengthened borders” had ranked near the top of voters’ priority list, often right below the economy.  As we begin the Trump Presidency sequel, it is clear that the incoming administration is planning to wield tariffs as a critical negotiating tool. The possibility of tariffs on “ALL” products coming from Mexico and the Canada throws a series of wild cards into the mix.

  • In the longer term, if imports are taxed at 25%, WSD foresees a possibility of an ensuing inflationary event. The 11+ million net tons of steel imported into the U.S. from Mexico and Canada accounts for more than 10 percent of steel consumed in the United States, and the immediate levy of a 25 percent tax would be undoubtedly inflationary for the U.S. market.

 

  • Furthermore, there is the issue of imported scrap. In 2023, the USA imported nearly 2 million tons of shredded and prime scrap from Canada with 4.7 million tons of scrap imports in total. Supply-demand dynamics for scrap (particularly premium grades) are already in the process of tightening with the opening of three new EAFs in the USA/Canada over the next six months: U.S. Steel’s BRS-II facility, ArcelorMittal’s Calvert facility, and Algoma’s new EAF. An additional 25 percent cost for a sizeable portion of the scrap market supply (from the viewpoint of USA sheet mills) is material. 

 

  • Taken together, the wild card effect of a 25 percent “All products tariff” should be viewed as a potential price-floor raising event for USA HRC prices in the first half of 2025. (Note: WSD views the long-term implementation of these measures as far from assured – although the measure could be put into effect initially, a prolonged negotiation with both Canada and Mexico is likely to follow as the USMCA is essentially re-written with the ultimate outcome for steel-related items (including steel products and raw materials such as scrap) likely to reflect a more moderate rate of tariffs, if any.)

 

USMCA Ferrous Trade Matrix          
(thousand net tons)          
           
Imports          
  2015 2020 2021 2022 2023
Sheet Products          
Canda 2.928 3.174 4.108 3.840 3.605
Mexico 784 627 1.172 1.536 1.073
Total 3.712 3.801 5.280 5.376 4.677
           
All Steel          
Canada 5.737 5.074 6.756 6.670 6.691
Mexico 2.843 3.469 5.017 5.464 4.353
Total 8.580 8.543 11.773 12.133 11.045
           
Steel Scrap          
Canada 3.073 3.503 4.141 3.867 3.921
Mexico 258 548 619 691 842
Total 3.331 4.051 4.760 4.558 4.762
           
Exports          
  2015 2020 2021 2022 2023
Sheet Products          
Canda 2.695 1.724 2.132 2.217 2.273
Mexico 2.813 2.309 2.998 3.002 3.448
Total 5.508 4.033 5.129 5.219 5.721
           
All Steel          
Canada 2.329 1.465 1.812 1.776 1.959
Mexico 1.060 617 931 935 924
Total 3.389 2.082 2.743 2.711 2.883
           
Steel Scrap          
Canada 743 1.143 883 956 865
Mexico 1.265 2.275 3.443 3.906 2.878
Total 2.009 3.419 4.326 4.863 3.744
DemetKazdal
Demet Kazdal
Editor

After graduating from Boğaziçi University with a degree in English Language and Literature, I have spent the past 15 years developing deep expertise in the steel industry. At SteelOrbis, I serve as Head of Content Department. I write and edit comprehensive news and reports on steel markets, with a primary focus on the Turkish market as well as global market dynamics.

Similar articles

Brazilian slab export prices hold steady amid expectations of stability

Brazilian slab export prices dip slightly; outlook uncertain as US dollar strengthens

Brazilian slab export prices rise on currency shift to weaker US dollar

US proposes expanding Section 232 tariffs to 14 additional derivative product categories

Brazil welcomes US decision to exempt pig iron from higher import tariffs

US flat steel pricing continues up to three-year highs despite more claims of peak pricing

Sindifer president remains optimistic Brazil can avoid new US pig iron tariffs

Sindifer: Tariffs on pig iron might push half of producers in Minas Gerais out of market

Brazilian negotiators remain pessimistic on US-Brazil pig iron tariff trade talks

Moody’s expects Mexico to retain preferential US market access under USMCA