Matthew Nolan: More trade suits not doing US steel industry any favors

Wednesday, 04 February 2015 01:22:35 (GMT+3)   |   San Diego

During his presentation at SteelOrbis’ sixth annual Rebar & Wire Rod conference in Las Vegas February 2, Matthew Nolan of Arent Fox pointed out that there were around 400 trade legislation measures in place in 2010, rising to over 1,600 in 2014. The US is the second-biggest trade case initiator, with metals making up about 35 percent of all cases in the last year or so. But Nolan isn’t convinced this is helping the US steel industry, especially when US producers pour so much time and energy into cases from which they probably won’t benefit.

Nolan used the recent rebar trade case between the US and Turkey as an example, noting that it was prosecuted more vigorously than most steel cases, and yet the result was zero percent AD margins and CVD margins too low to make any impact on prices. The subsides, Nolan explained later in the Q&A session, did not arise from Turkish mills getting free or discounted energy from the government, as US petitioners alleged—some Turkish mills have their own power plant to run their facilities, and because energy is a close second in input costs behind raw materials, the savings are much more substantial than they would be if a US mill did the same. Either way, Nolan said, the insistence of US producers that there is no legal way Turkish mills can sell rebar as cheaply as they do, is part of a “silly season” trend in trade law that is obscuring the validity of legitimate grievances.

Marketplace Offers

Deformed Bar

Diameter 8 - 40 mm
 
Tedarikçi CONARES METAL SUPPLY
View Offer

Deformed Bar

Diameter 6 - 32 mm
  ES ISO 6935-2 2019 B500BWR , ASTM A615 GR 60
Tedarikçi YOTTA TRADING
View Offer

Deformed Bar

Diameter 8 - 32 mm
 
Tedarikçi SHATTAF STEEL IND. CO. LLC.
View Offer

Similar articles

Tensions run high at RWR 2014

Steel Scene longs panel: Are dumping cases on the horizon for the US’ wire rod and rebar market?

RWR 2012: Concerns and hopes along the long product supply spectrum

IREPAS committees agree: Outlook for demand is positive

US rebar mills may be on to something

Andrés Barceló: European steel production is led by exports

Attendees of the SteelOrbis Steel Trade conference "look for the light"

Domestic long steel prices steady to up on outlook for steady to higher December scrap

Turkish mills keep local rebar prices stable, spot prices in liras also unchanged

Bulgarian rebar prices extend gains despite weak market outlook