WTO rules in favor of Turkish HRC producers in AD dispute with Morocco

Friday, 02 November 2018 10:04:22 (GMT+3)   |   San Diego
       

A World Trade Organization panel ruled this week in favor of the Turkish steelmakers Colakoglu and Erdemir, according to news reports, with the panel concluding that the Moroccan government violated international trade rules when enacting antidumping duties on imports of hot rolled steel from Turkey.

Turkey prevailed on nearly all of its substantive challenges to the duties implemented by Morocco’s investigative trade agency (MDCCE). The panel faulted MDCCE for “adverse inferences” made in the calculation of the duties, along with the manner in which it conducted an accompanying probe into whether Turkish imports injured domestic producers.

Colakoglu and Erdemir had initially obtained zero dumping margins in the original investigation but subsequently MDCCE increased the dumping margins to 11 percent.

The panel found that MDCCE dismissed certain data presented by Turkish producers and instead crafting its duties using “facts available,” a method meant for punishing companies that do not sufficiently cooperate with an investigation. MDCCE also reportedly violated the antidumping agreement by completing the investigation beyond the 18-month period prescribed by WTO rules, and relied too heavily on flawed industrial analysis prepared by steel consulting firm McLellan and Partners Ltd., which “polluted the government's injury finding.”

“The MDCCE, in relying in its injury analysis on the McLellan report … without properly investigating the significance of inaccuracies in that report, did not base its injury determination on an objective examination, and therefore acted inconsistently with … the Anti-Dumping Agreement,” the panel wrote in its decision.

Turkey originally filed the suit in October 2016. Both sides have 60 days to appeal the decision, and if the ruling is upheld on appeal, Morocco will have to remove or reconfigure its antidumping duties.


Similar articles

Flat steel prices in local Taiwanese market - week 17, 2024

25 Apr | Flats and Slab

Major steel and raw material futures prices in China – Apr 25, 2024 

25 Apr | Longs and Billet

Stocks of main finished steel products in China down 5.4% in mid-April

25 Apr | Steel News

China issues serious warnings to non-VAT exporters, effect on prices too uneven so far

24 Apr | Flats and Slab

Import HRC offers lack clarity in Turkey amid non-VAT trade probe in China

24 Apr | Flats and Slab

Ex-China CRC offer prices rise slightly despite slow trade

24 Apr | Flats and Slab

Ex-Japan HRC prices fall in April, so exports sales accelerate, price trend may reverse in May

24 Apr | Flats and Slab

GCC buyers favor ex-Japan HRC as low Chinese prices off the table

24 Apr | Flats and Slab

Import HRC prices rise in new deals in Vietnam, outlook dimmed by non-VAT investigation in China

24 Apr | Flats and Slab

China’s Wu’an Xin Feng to build HRC plant in Egypt

24 Apr | Steel News